New PSNI search guidance is confusion dressed up as compassion

< Back To News

New PSNI search guidance is confusion dressed up as compassion

Ulster Unionist Party leader Jon Burrows MLA has criticised new PACE guidance from Justice Minister Naomi Long instructing the PSNI to seek out female officers willing to search males who identify as women, branding it a dereliction of duty that leaves frontline officers without clear rules.

Jon Burrows MLA said:

“Naomi Long’s department has once again put the burden of accommodating gender identity onto ordinary officers and staff, rather than giving them clear, workable rules. It’s a clear dereliction of duty.

“Asking the PSNI to hunt for a female officer willing to search a biological male, and only falling back on biological sex when that search proves impossible, is not clarity. It’s confusion dressed up as compassion. Officers need certainty when they’re carrying out searches, not a hierarchy of preferences to navigate in real time, often in pressured custody situations.

“The Supreme Court was clear that sex means biological sex. Interim guidance that only reaches that position as a last resort, and still requires officers to weigh a detainee’s self-declared ‘predominant lifestyle,’ does not reflect that clarity. It puts frontline officers in an invidious position and risks the dignity and safety of female police officers.

“It must be made abundantly clear that no female officer will ever be pressured into searching for a biological male.

“Having served as a police officer, I know how much officers rely on straightforward rules for something as sensitive as a search.

“This latest intervention from the Justice Minister follows her refusal to guarantee that biological men can never be placed in women’s prisons in Northern Ireland.”